Best Comment Plugin for WordPress Websites
If you run an interactive website or blog like WordPress, then allowing visitors to leave comments on our posts is something you will conside to do especially if your blog traffic is growing. There are several reasons for this and we will consider those in greater detail later. Blog comments do have advantages just as they also have disadvantages and can actally hurt your website SEO efforts. Blog comments not only help you engage with your readers, they can be quite helpful for your site rank too just as when abused can also hurt your site ranking on Google too.
If you choose to have comments enabled on your website, one easy way to do it is to use WordPress plugins. Plugins actually do it better and are much more a secure way to handle comments on your website. They are, in fact, available in such huge numbers that you might feel overwhelmed trying to find the absolute best options. We suggest that you do not fucus on what is best but rather pay attention to the plugin that serves your purpose.
In this post, we have compiled a collection of the most resommended, what can be described as the best comment plugins for WordPress. But before we go into that, let us take a look at how commenting can help grow a website.
You will also want to read:
Why Commenting is Good for a Website
We have here outlined some of the good side og commenting on a website.
This will go as the most beneficial aspect of commenting on any website. People often comment on a website and suport their position with a link for referal purposes and to build link for SEO purposes. This has not been a good one for Google esppecially when people ust add links that are of little and no value to the topic under discussion or is completely unrelated Some webmasters have used commenting to generate trafic to websites but we advice that the links must be related and offer real value to the users and not just designed to build link.
When you comment on blogs, it helps create backlinks, which in turn generates traffic. Most of these links are no-follow links and thus, carry little SEO value; however, the process is still helpful for users if it provide a guide to help solve problems.
This is most useful for new blogs. Commenting can help faster indexing.
Traffic Building for your website
Commenting helps drive traffic to your blog. The key thing here is be sure your coments are valuable and not spammy. Take advantage of comment thraeds to build and maintain traffic to your website. The focus is on adding value to your website
Commenting is a delicate issue. just as it come with benefits, it can also have a problem as some comments can be considered to be spammy. We suggest you take these rules seriously when allowing commenting on your website:
- Try to be the first to comment.
- Write detailed comments that are informative and valuable to the discussion.
- Make sure you have an image associated with your email address.
- You can use Gravatar.com for assistance.
Commenting with your keyword as a name has a great advantage in terms of SEO, though many bloggers (including me) will see it as a spam and not accept such comments. When you comment, try to do so without promoting your self so that ou can add value to your post and our your comments will be gratefully accepted.
Search Engine Optimization
The importance of SEO for any website cannot be over-emphasized. Going by the ruules above and ensuring that comments on your posts are beneficial to users and not seen as spam by the search engines can be of real SEO benefits to your website. Instead of having spammy comments on your blog,it is better to avoid commenting at all by disabling it.
By giving quality comments, you will be performing great offsite SEO and increasing your chances of building high-quality backlinks. We advice that you take the following seriously:
- Comment using your keyword as a name (might trigger spam).
- Comment on blogs with do-follow comment policies.
- Comment on blogs using the Top Commentator widget.
Remember that your comments must add value to your website and mae your ost more meaningful
Commenting is one best way to connect with any blogger, maintain a relationship and contribute to the commnity. While it can take time to create meaningful connections, once you are regularly commenting, you will be noticed by the site’s administrator and your co-bloggers. The development of these connections can prove to be very helpful to you in the long term.
Statistical Evidence in Favour and Against Commenting
Deciding on wether to enable or disable commenting on your website can be guided by the evidence drawn fro statistics regarding be benefits and the problems associated with commenting on a blog. In this section, we’ll look at what the data shows about allowing blog comments or not on a website.
The results indicate a mixed reaction and suggests that commenting enabled cound both be beneficial as well as harmful. You will eep in mind the guide we have made above and ensure your somments do not appear to be spammy. Lets look at what some results associated with high traffic and top raning websites suggest.
In 2014, Copyblogger announced that they were removing comments, two years later, in 2016, they brought comments back.
Another big time blogger, Michael Hyatt pulled the comments section from his blog, after a year, he brought back the comment box again
One blogger, Zen Habits turned off their comments permanently due to too much spam.
Seth Godin says that, while he thinks comments are terrific, they take up too much of his time and energy, so he will never allow them.
On the other hand, many publishers still argue the case for keeping blog comments.
Without a clear consensus from the content marketing community, how are you supposed to decide what to do with the comments on your own blog? Particularly when you are inundated by tons of spammy or low-quality comments?
Deciding Whether or Not to Disable Comments
Getting the views of top bloggers may be helpful here:
Pat Flynn argue that,
“Without comments, a blog isn’t really a blog. To me, blogging is not just about publishing content, but also the two-way communication and community building aspects behind it.”
The benefits he states for allowing blog comments are:
- Blog comments provide a form of social proof
- Blog comments help you to understand what your readers want you to write about
- Responding to comments helps you to deepen your relationship with your readers
- The act of commenting theoretically increases the likelihood that the user will also engage in other ways, such as subscribing to your newsletter, or even making a purchase down the road
Everett Bogue argues that,
“To say a blog is not a blog when it doesn’t have comments can’t be true, because my blog works just fine without comments. My ideas are definitely not perfect, but at a certain point I had to make a decision about where my focus would lie. Did I want hordes of Internet randoms deciding where my ideas needed to go, or did I want to proactively choose the opinions that would influence my ideas?”
He goes on to say that rather than spending endless amounts of time sifting through low-quality comments on his blog, he now has time to build meaningful relationships with individuals on social media.
So which argument makes the most sense for your readers and your business? Let’s take a look at what the statistics says.
Going By The Data
As far as your content marketing is concerned, you can safely assume that the more traffic you get, the more revenue you’ll be able to generate. So the question becomes, do blog comments lead to more traffic?
According to HubSpot's analysis of view and link data from over 100,000 blog posts, the analysis found that there is no correlation between the number of comments on a post and the number of links that post got. There is also no correlation between the number of comments and the number of views that post got.
(There is, however, a positive correlation between links and views, which is exactly what you would expect.)
So, the data shows that blog comments are not correlated with increased traffic.
Neil Patel also published some data in regard to whether or not blog comments generate more search traffic.
The theory is that the more blog comments you have, the more content you’ll have on each page, and the more keywords you should rank for, which should increase your overall search traffic. However, Neil was not convinced that this is actually the case, so he did some research.
First Neil found that he averages about 176 comments per post, with 22.6 words per comment, which means that allowing blog comments nets him an average of 3,978 extra words on each page.
Next, he checked Google Analytics and Google Webmaster Tools to see whether the blog comments were resulting in more search engine rankings. He found that approx. 26.7% of the keywords that were ranking in Google were from the comments section.
However, to figure out how much additional traffic he was receiving from those rankings, Neil took a look at the actual number of impressions and clicks that those rankings received.
Overall, Neil concluded that he found that the comments section brought in 16% of all search traffic.
“Comments didn’t drive as many visitors as I wanted, but considering that it’s user-generated content, it’s not that bad. It could be that Google may not be placing as much value on text created through comments or words appearing lower on a page (since comments are located below each blog post) as it does on the post itself.”
Michael Hyatt made the decision to eliminate his comments section due to the sheer amount of low-quality comments he was receiving, plus the fact that social media is where most meaningful conversations seem to be happening nowadays. In his announcement, he shared his perception of blog comments compared to blog traffic.
For Micheal, his traffic shot up by 74% while his average comments per post steadily declined year after year.
While Michael did later bring his comments section back, he explained that it was not because it had a huge negative effect on his blog traffic. It was because he wanted his blog to feel more hospitable.
All of this shows that comments are not a reliable indicator of blog traffic. If you have a high-quality comment section, you may see a slight boost in traffic from Google, but it probably isn’t going to be so huge that you can’t consider eliminating your comments section if you really wanted to.
WordPress Comment Plugins
Now, you can see that we have reasons to allow or to disallow blog comments on a website. If you choose to enable blog comments, here are recommended plugins you can go with;
1. Thrive Comments
This is a relatively new plugin from the stable of Thrive Themes. It wors excellently well and will serve you uite well. Thrive Comments integrates with the native WordPress comments system to add a completely new interface:
Thrive Comments adds helpful engagement-boosting features like:
- Upvotes and downvotes on comments like Reddit (you can also just use upvotes if you don’t like the negative aspect of downvotes)
- Social login for comments
- Custom gamification badges for things like numbers of comments or upvotes
- The option to display a custom message or offer after a user leaves a comment. Great for boosting social shares, promoting offers, or building your email list.
- A custom moderation panel that makes it easy to control your comments
Analytics for your comments section
2. No Self Pings
No Self Pings is a simple plugin that helps keep your comments section free of clutter. By default, every time that you link to an internal post on your WordPress site, your site will leave a pingback on the post that you linked to.
If you’re following good SEO principles and including lots of internal links, this can quickly start cluttering up your comments section with lots of pingbacks.
When you install and activate this plugin, you’ll get a new box when you go to Settings → Discussion that lets you enter domains to exclude from pings. By default, the plugin already includes your own domain name, but you can also add additional domain names if you want to exclude external websites:
3. Jetpack Comments
Jetpack Comments is a module in the all-purpose Jetpack plugin that replaces your blog’s comment form with a new form that lets visitors use social login to comment on your site. It doesn’t affect how your theme displays comments – it just affects the form that your readers use to actually leave comments.
Another benefit that Jetpack Comments comes with is the ease of use to enable in comparison to other social login plugins. Most plugins make you create a Facebook App before you start accepting social login, but with Jetpack you just need to click a single button:
wpDiscuz aims to offer many of the same features of the Disqus comments platform in a WordPress-specific plugin.
Similar to Thrive Comments, it completely replaces your comments section design with a new one.
In addition to the new design, here are some other features that wpDiscuz adds to your comments section:
- Comments voting (just like Reddit and Thrive Comments)
- Comments sorting for visitors can find new, old, or most-voted comments
- Multi-level nested comments so that visitors can more easily follow specific comment threads
- AJAX “Load More Comments” button so that visitors can load more comments without needing to reload the page
- Anonymous users can edit comments (but only for a timeframe that you set)
- Social share buttons for users to share comments
- Option for commenters to subscribe to your email list
There are also a lot of smaller features in wpDiscuz. If you’re interested, I encourage you to check out the demo.
5. Thank Me Later
Thank Me Later lets you connect with your commenters via email after they leave a comment on your site. This plugin lets you automatically send an email to your commenters at a specific time after they leave a comment. You can specify the timeframe – so this could be 15 minutes or 3 days after they leave a comment.
You can use this email to:
- Simply thank your readers for the comment
- Promote something (like your social media profiles or a special offer)
Another good side is that you can also use shortcodes in your emails to automatically insert the commenter’s name, which gives your thank you email a more personalized touch:
6. WP First Letter Avatar
WordPress displays a grey “Mystery Person” avatar whenever a user doesn’t have a Gravatar image associated with their email. With WP First Letter Avatar, you avoid a bunch of anonymous grey “Mystery Person” boxes by adding an avatar with the first letter of the commenter’s name when WordPress can’t find a Gravatar image:
7. Yoast Comment Hacks
Yoast Comment Hacks is a plugin from the Yoast SEO team that makes a few minor tweaks to how your comments section functions. One good feature of this plugin is a new button in your interface that lets you email all commenters on a specific post. This plugin is also good in the sense that it lets you redirect first-time commenters to a special thank you page.
Other features of this plugin worthy of note include:
- Better comment notification emails
- Option to disallow comments that are too short or too long
- Some other basic maintenance options
8. Simple Comment Editing
This plugin is particularly helpful because it lests you edit a comment you have already submitted and ou think you have not popely presented what you had to say. Simple Comment Editing helps your visitors avoid feeling bad by giving even anonymous commenters the option to edit comments after they click submit.
There is also a limitetion and so they can’t edit comments forever (that would cause all kinds of problems). Instead, they only have 5 minutes to edit their comment. To use this plugin, you simply install/activate it and it starts working right away – no configuration needed:
Now you can take a decision on wether to allow comments on your website or not to.
Don't forget to let us now if there is something we have missed or something you think should be added.